You’ve sat through this meeting before. A new technology is presented, promising (or threatening) to reshape your marketing strategy. But the path forward isn’t clear, the metrics aren’t standardised, and the benefits are still largely theoretical.

This time it’s AI search. And the board wants to know what you’re doing about it.

Perhaps the safe move is to wait. Marketers have been burned before. Remember the claim that 50% of all searches would be voice searches by 2020? Those voice search optimisation budgets that followed rarely delivered on their promised returns.

Virtual reality? NFTs? We’ve seen a few technologies fail to make as big a splash in marketing as the initial hype suggested.

So, let others test the waters and take the risks, then implement a strategy once the methodologies and likely returns are proven.

But with AI search, this wait-and-see strategy risks compounding competitive disadvantage over time rather than avoiding wasted effort.

The AI adoption curve

Devised by Everett Rogers in 1962, the Diffusion of Innovations curve is a handy framework for understanding how new technologies spread through society.

The first 2.5% of the market are innovators. They’re followed by early adopters (13.5%). Once adoption approaches roughly 15–20%, technologies typically begin crossing into the early majority – the phase where behaviours shift at scale, and the gap Geoffrey Moore labelled “the chasm” in Crossing the Chasm (1991).

That transition is where competitive advantage is redistributed.

AI search appears to be evolving slightly differently from Rogers’ model. Clickstream research from Datos and SparkToro suggests AI isn’t replacing existing search behaviour – it’s integrating into it. AI is becoming a decision layer within discovery rather than a wholesale substitute.

SparkToro’s analysis of US clickstream data shows that between January 2023 and June 2025, Americans who regularly used AI tools rose from 8% to 38%. However, 95% kept using traditional search engines regularly.

That transition is still where competitive advantage is redistributed. Not because usage suddenly explodes, but because default information sources become entrenched.

So where does AI sit today?

ChatGPT reached 900 million weekly active users in February 2026, according to figures OpenAI shared at the time.

Against the 6 billion people the ITU estimates were online in 2025, that’s about 15% – right where Rogers’ curve says the early majority starts. That’s for just ChatGPT, before accounting for Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, and Perplexity. Weekly users differ from searchers, and not every session is a search, but the scale is material.

Not all of those users are replacing traditional search. In fact, the Datos data shows that traditional search remains stable and dominant while AI usage grows alongside it. And not all AI interactions are search-driven. But at this scale, AI-assisted information discovery is no longer experimental. It is embedded in everyday workflows across consumer and professional contexts.

Historically, once technologies reach this level of ubiquity, behavioural acceleration tends to follow. More importantly, the sources AI systems treat as defaults start to settle before usage looks “mainstream” in analytics.

For CMOs, that distinction matters.

Because by the time adoption is unquestionably mainstream, the strategic advantage will already belong to brands that invested during the transition phase – not after it.

The analysis paralysis problem

In large organisations, CMOs are expected to be the experts in the room when it comes to effective marketing strategy, working with extremely precise KPIs. But that becomes a problem when proven methodologies for AI optimisation don’t yet exist, never mind precise KPIs.

This creates a dangerous paradox. The larger the organisation, the higher the stakes, and the greater the demand for data-driven certainty.

In practice, the teams we see moving first track a short stack they can actually measure. This includes AI-driven referral traffic where it appears, AI crawler activity in server logs, and brand inclusion in answers to priority prompts.

More advanced teams are beginning to track “share-of-answer” visibility across priority prompts, brand inclusion rates versus competitors, and patterns of AI-assisted conversion journeys.

However, these KPIs alone won’t reveal the full story. AI systems evolve rapidly, and measurement frameworks will continue to mature.

Even when companies do commit to action, another trap awaits: analysis paralysis. It’s easy to get stuck researching and debating the “right” approach instead of actually implementing anything.

The solution? Start small, test incrementally, and adapt quickly. There is no data to light the way ahead except for what you can generate yourself by simply getting on with it.

The businesses that will dominate AI search aren’t waiting for perfect KPIs or standardised methodologies. They’re experimenting now, learning what works, and building the expertise that will matter when AI search reaches full maturity.

What does investing in AI search look like?

The good news is that optimising for AI search doesn’t require massive budgets or entirely new skill sets. You rarely need a greenfield redesign or a new tech stack to start.

The highest-leverage investment remains relevant, original content that delivers genuine value to the right audience, with clear page structure, solid technical foundations, and data AI systems can interpret. If that advice sounds anti-climactic, almost mundane, that might be because the best SEOs and content marketers have been shouting this message for at least a decade, long before the arrival of AI search.

Systems that retrieve and synthesise live web content when forming answers, such as Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode, reward clarity, authority, and well-structured expertise when choosing sources. Dive into more detail in our guide to evolving content strategy for generative AI search.

The shift isn’t just where people search, but how they ask. Queries are becoming longer and more explicit, meaning authoritative explanation increasingly beats keyword coverage.

Those brands already investing in original, well-researched, in-depth content (especially when it’s organised into content hubs) are well placed to capitalise on AI search with less effort required than their competitors.

The businesses likely to struggle are those relying on outdated SEO tactics, churning out mountains of listicles and other thin content while aggressively acquiring backlinks. Those pages are weak candidates as AI answers favour deep, well-sourced content.

If your content strategy is more about quantity than quality, more about keywords than thought leadership, then now is the time to change course.

The defensive dimension

There is also a defensive risk that many brands are underestimating.

If you are not actively shaping the content AI systems rely on, those systems may default to competitor positioning, outdated third-party sources, or incomplete descriptions when representing your brand.

AI systems are probabilistic and imperfect. They synthesise from available sources. If your authoritative voice is absent or unclear, assistants may select competitors instead. Regular competitor analysis in AI search shows you where that’s already happening.

And because AI answers increasingly satisfy informational intent directly, your brand may never enter the click journey at all.

In that sense, investing in AI visibility is an offensive growth strategy and is increasingly a brand governance and reputation management strategy.

Where to start: Your first 90 days

Here’s what an effective first quarter looks like. Assign one owner across SEO and content so the findings become actioned changes, not just a report.

Weeks 1–2: Set a baseline 

Pick 20 to 30 prompts your buyers are likely to ask an assistant – for example, “best payroll software for a UK manufacturer with 200 staff”, not just “payroll software”. Run each of these across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google AI Mode. Record when your brand appears and how it’s described, as well as where it’s absent and who surfaces instead.

Weeks 3–4: Check AI systems can reach your site

Review server logs for AI crawler activity, and make sure your most important pages aren’t blocked, gated, or reliant on JavaScript to display key content.

Weeks 5–10: Close the most valuable gaps first

Check where competitors are cited instead of you and strengthen or build in-depth pages that answer buyers’ highest-value questions.

Weeks 5–10: Correct brand descriptions

Identify any instances where AI answers describe your brand incorrectly or use outdated sources. Update and correct your pages and third-party profiles where they source this information.

Weeks 11–12: Report and decide

Share AI referral traffic, crawler activity, and answer inclusion with leadership. Present this as early learning, and prioritise prompts and pages to focus on next quarter.

The time to act is now

We’re at a pivotal moment. AI search is moving rapidly from experimentation to embedded behaviour by influencing decisions earlier in the discovery process.

Defaults are still forming in this transition window. From where we sit, that’s exactly why brands can still shape inclusion before AI visibility becomes table stakes.

Don’t wait for someone else to solve all the problems and hand you a bunch of best practices. By the time something has become a best practice, there’s very little competitive advantage left to be gained from it. Your strategy will be lagging months or even years behind the competition.

The competitive edge, on the other hand, comes from a willingness to get out in front of the pack, to pioneer the practices that might eventually crystallise into tomorrow’s best practices for others to follow.

In AI search, advantage doesn’t arrive when adoption spikes. It locks in while behaviour is still stabilising.

Pioneers shape the landscape while followers inherit it. It’s time to choose.

Not sure where to start? Our AI search optimisation experts can run your baseline and show how you compare to competitors. Get in touch to discuss your project.